Dr. Shuster is an Atlanta native and the son of Dr. Abe Shuster and Mrs. Sue Shuster. Growing up in Atlanta, Dr. Shuster attended Pace Academy. Following high school, Dr. Casey attended Southern Methodist University , where he earned a BA in Political Science and a minor in Sociology.

From 2015-2019, Dr. Shuster attended Boston University Henry M. Goldman School of Dental Medicine, ultimately graduating with Cum Laude honors. Boston University provided Dr. Shuster opportunities to excel in the fields of digital dentistry, cosmetic dentistry, invisalign treatment, and implant dentistry.

Following graduation, he joined the Practice of Dr. Jeffrey Smith, a renowned Atlanta dentist, and the then dentist for the Atlanta Braves and the Atlanta United. Following Dr. Smith’s retirement in 2020, Dr. Shuster assumed the role as the lead dentist for the practice and has sought to carry on the legacy of high quality dentistry that the practice has always been known for.

In his free time, Dr. Casey enjoys golf, swimming, working out, and spending time with his friends and family. Dr. Shuster is a member of the Georgia Dental Association, the American Dental Association, and the Hinman Society. He currently serves as the team dentist for the Atlanta United Soccer Team.